Coal

Coal and Clean Energy Reporting Across Southeast Asia in 2020

“The climate battle will succeed or fail in Asia”—an often-quoted phrase in climate media since UN officials uttered it last year, and for good reason. Asia, specifically Southeast Asia, is one of the fastest-developing regions globally with an energy demand growth rate twice as fast as the rest of the world—and a coal demand growth rate of more than 5 percent annually through 2024. In Philippines and Indonesia, coal already makes up more than 50 percent of total energy output. 

Whether Southeast Asia turns to dirty coal or green energy to supply this demand may well determine the world’s progress in meeting necessary carbon cuts to stay below the IPCC-recommended 1.5-degree increase. 

Marking the turn of the decade, 2020, more than any other year, is important for the future of energy in the region—Vietnam is about to release its Master Power Development Plan for the next ten years, while the Philippines’ Department of Energy is planning to triple the current amount of coal in the country, despite divestment pressures from a domestic energy producer and international financial institutions. Meanwhile in Indonesia, much speculation has arisen about whether the coal industry can survive the global recession. 

But has the media in Southeast Asia given this incredible energy and climate risk its due attention, especially in the midst of the COVID-19 threat that is still ravaging lives and economies in the region? 

Over the course of two weeks in June and July, 19 veteran journalists and media researchers from five Southeast Asian countries conducted a short media analysis of coal and renewable energy reporting as part of Climate Tracker’s Research Fellowship. The results of their study shed much light on this question, as they considered the quantity and quality of energy reporting in the first six months of 2020. 

Denise Alcantara, a researcher from the Philippines, exclusively focused her study on how energy reporting changed from before to after the pandemic lockdown. Two major news networks Alcantara studied—Abs-cbn and Gmanetwork—increased publishing renewable-related stories during quarantine,” while the Inquirer and Rappler, often cited as the best climate publications in the country, decreased their coverage. 

Overall, this brought the number of energy stories published before and during quarantine to be equal—signifying continued interest in the topic. Alcantara linked this momentum in the media to the “return-to-nature” sentiment often expressed during lockdown, citing an open letter to future leaders signed by 300 scientists and conservation groups in April that received much attention. 

Interestingly, the majority of articles Alcantara analyzed were listed under the “Business and Money” category, as Filipino media most commonly  approached through a purely business lens, with extensie quotes from CEOs. Another Filipino researcher, Jason Paolo Telles, also noticed the same pattern, citing 13 out of 15 articles analyzed as business-focused.  

In Vietnam, environmental journalists did not seem to lose sight of the bigger picture either—at least not at Saigon Times, the leading business and economics news magazine in the country.  According to Vietnamese researcher Nguyen Nguyen, the articles also demonstrated a more balanced approach; roughly two dozen pieces were published in the first half of this year, many of which featured NGO, expert and locals’ perspectives. Nguyen credited the release of new policy statements as the source of journalists’ interest in the topic, as is typical in this country. 

As a percentage of total articles published in Vietnam however, the number of energy articles is still low—accounting for less than 2 percent for VnExpress and VietnamPlus total output, according to researcher Mi Hoang

Meanwhile in Thailand, researcher Chalefun Ditphudee concluded after her study of three online news sources that “during the Thailand Covid-19 lockdown situation [from April 4 to mid-May], these online media platforms temporarily paused their reporting on coal..” 

Renewable energy-related articles before and during quarantine in the Philippines | Graph by Denise Alcantara

Before and after the lockdown, however, the national outlook for climate news was more positive. COVID-19 served as a new lens through which climate and energy topics were approached. According to researcher Sippachai Kunnuwong, 27 percent of all examined climate change articles this year from Thai Rath Online and Bangkok Biz Online are related to the COVID-19. Commonly featured story types were opinion pieces about a post-COVID “new normal”  and renewable energy solutions to economic recession. 

Glaringly lacking were environmental activism stories, a fact which PPTV reporter Afnan Abdulloh attributed to COVID social distancing measures in an interview with Kunnuwong. It seems that digital activism is less capable of drawing mainstream media attention than traditional methods.  

Malaysian researcher Maisarah Kadir noticed the same gap in energy coverage in her country’s major newspaper The Star, which mostly focused on electricity affordability during and after the pandemic. 

In Indonesia, researcher Cherika Hardjakusumah similarly found that even though newspapers covered renewables, especially solar energy, the most-often mentioned topics were cost, capacity and investment. Environmental impact of renewables versus coal was hardly considered.  

Taken as a whole, media research in five Southeast Asian countries—Malaysia, Vietnam, Thailand, Indonesia and Philippines—showed that energy coverage during the first six months of 2020: 

  • Decreased during COVID-19 lockdown, but remained stable before and after lockdown despite the ongoing pandemic. 
  • Mostly focused on business aspects of energy projects and affordability. 
  • When mentioning the environment, usually approached it through the lens of a “new normal,” less carbon-intensive post-pandemic reality. 
  • Lacked human stories and the perspective of environmental activists. 
slot gacor maxwin slot thailand slot thailand slot thailand slot thailand sv388 slot kamboja idn slot slot ovo habanero slot petir slot dana slot maxwin slot ovo starlight princess live casino slot zeus pg soft slot olympus ibcbet maxwin slot thailand slot pgsoft slot slot mahjong zeus slot digmaan slot mania slot pulsa jdb slot slot777 slot shopee slot spade gaming slot thailand slot thailand fafaslot nolimit city slot princess fafaslot fafa slot slot princess slot gacor slot thailand slot mahjong slot gopay slot88 slot toto slot server thailand slot thailand slot77 slot gacor slot thailand slot server thailand slot thailand akun gacor slot maxwin slot gacor slot thailand slot kakek zeus Pg Soft Maxbet Ibcbet Starlight Princess Slot Ovo Joker123 Mahjong Ways 2 Sv388 Sbobet Slot Dana Slot Thailand Slot Thailand Digmaan Sv388 Joker123 Mahjong Ways 2 Slot Dana Slot Gacor Slot Anti Rungkat baccarat roulette sicbo casino online sv388 tembak ikan online sbobet slot macau slot thailand slot thailand slot88 situs slot wwg slot wm casino tembak ikan slot thailand slot wala meron slot nolimit city slot pg slot gacor slot88 slot50000 slot mahjong slot thailand 66k bet slot daftar judi slot online indonesia slot mahjong ways slot thailand mahjong ways slot gacor slot mawin slot gacor slot gacor slot gacor slot thailand slot thailand slot gacor slot ovo slot gacor slot gopay slot gacor slot gacor slot thailand slot gacor judi slot slot thailand slot thailand slot thailand slot mahjong ways 2 slot pragmatic slot demo pragmatic slot demo pg soft demo slot pragmatic slot gacor 4d slot pg soft pgslot pgsoft pgsoft sv388 slot88 pgsoft slot thailand slot88 slot thailand slot gacor slot ovo slot dana fafaslot slot ovo slot jepang judi slot gacor slot rusia Situs Daftar Judi Slot Mahjong Ways 1 dan 2 PG Soft Online PG Soft : Daftar Situs Judi Slot Online Gacor Slot Kakek Zeus RTP Slot > Daftar Situs Judi Slot Gacor Mahjong Ways 2 PG Soft : Daftar Situs Judi Slot Online Gacor Terbaik Situs Slot Online Gacor Dan Agen Slot Pragmatic Play Terpercaya Slot Gacor: Situs Slot Online Pragmatic Play & Bocoran Pola Slot Situs Slot Online Terbaik Terpercaya dan Terbesar di Indonesia Slot Kakek Zeus Daftar Link Slot Olympus Terbaru Slot Dana Daftar Judi Slot Online Indonesia Paling Gacor di Indonesia Sabung Ayam Online Sv388 Daftar Situs Judi Slot Online SLOT88 SLOT PG SOFT GACOR Bandar Slot Daftar Situs Judi Online Terbaik & Terpercaya Gacor power gaming sv388 lucky neko slot gacor slot gacor slot88 slot kakek slot pg slot kakek zeus slot dana slot maxwin slot server luar negeri slot thailand Link Daftar Situs Judi Slot Deposit Dana 20RB Tanpa Potongan Power Gaming : Situs Slot Gacor Online RTP Pragmatic Play Power Gaming : Situs Slot Gacor Online RTP Pragmatic Play Power Gaming : Situs Slot Gacor Online RTP Pragmatic Play Link Daftar Situs Judi Slot Deposit Dana 20RB Tanpa Potongan Slot Pragmatic - Link Alternatif Judi Slot Online Gacor Kakek Zeus Power Gaming : Situs Slot Gacor Online RTP Pragmatic Play Daftar Slot Dana Power Gaming : Situs Slot Gacor Online RTP Pragmatic Play lucky Neko Daftar & Login Slot PG Judi Slot 88 Online Power Gaming : Situs Slot Gacor Online RTP Pragmatic Play Power Gaming : Situs Slot Gacor Online RTP Pragmatic Play Power Gaming : Situs Slot Gacor Online RTP Pragmatic Play Power Gaming : Situs Slot Gacor Online RTP Pragmatic Play Power Gaming : Situs Slot Gacor Online RTP Pragmatic Play Power Gaming : Situs Slot Gacor Online RTP Pragmatic Play Power Gaming : Situs Slot Gacor Online RTP Pragmatic Play Power Gaming : Situs Slot Gacor Online RTP Pragmatic Play Power Gaming : Situs Slot Gacor Online RTP Pragmatic Play Power Gaming : Situs Slot Gacor Online RTP Pragmatic Play Slot Mahjong Ways 2 Mudah Jackpot Paus di PG Soft Hari ini 2023 Lucky Neko Situs Slot Gacor Pgsoft Hari Ini Slot Pragmatic - Link Alternatif Judi Slot Online Gacor Kakek Zeus SITUS SABUNG AYAM SV388 ONLINE DAFTAR LINK LOGIN APK AGEN SV388 Daftar Judi Slot Online Indonesia Paling Gacor di Indonesia SBOBET Login Agen Judi Bola Sbobet Mahjong Ways | Slot PG | Slot Mahjong Ways 2 | Slot PGsoft | Daftar Slot Mahjong Situs Joker123 | Joker123 | Joker Gaming | Daftar Slot Joker Power Gaming : Situs Slot Gacor Online RTP Pragmatic Play Agen Daftar Situs Judi Slot Online Terpercaya Slot Kakek Zeus : Daftar RTP Judi Slot Online Gacor Gampang Menang Joker123 Game Slot Gacor Joker Gaming Casino Online Indonesia Power Gaming : Situs Slot Gacor Online RTP Pragmatic Play